---
question: "why melanie barcenas"
status: "answered"
reading: "why Melanie Barcenas: her place among scorers (27) and her measures against Yazmeen Ryan and Emma Sears, either side"
mode: "computed"
as_of: "2026-11-11T20:40:46.451Z"
watermark: 2882841
url: "https://notebookfc.com/ask/why-melanie-barcenas"
verify: "https://notebookfc.com/v/why-melanie-barcenas?w=2882841&x=27c12bf7&r=6bd8c7792d"
pinned: "https://notebookfc.com/?a=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"
json: "https://notebookfc.com/ask/why-melanie-barcenas.json"
source: Notebook FC (notebookfc.com)
---

# Why Melanie Barcenas

Melanie Barcenas v Yazmeen Ryan: minutes 1,844 to 2,609, goals 7 to 7.

Read as: why Melanie Barcenas: her place among scorers (27) and her measures against Yazmeen Ryan and Emma Sears, either side. Computed from Notebook FC's record, as of November 11, 2026 at 3:40 PM ET.

| Measure | [Melanie Barcenas](https://notebookfc.com/ask/melanie-barcenas) | [Yazmeen Ryan](https://notebookfc.com/ask/yazmeen-ryan) | [Emma Sears](https://notebookfc.com/ask/emma-sears) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| minutes | 1,844 | 2,609 | 2,031 |
| goals | 7 | 7 | 7 |
| assists | 2 | 6 | 5 |
| xG |  |  |  |
| xA |  |  |  |
| shots | 61 | 71 | 52 |
| shots on target | 32 | 20 | 22 |
| goals per 90 | 0.34 | 0.24 | 0.31 |
| goals minus xG |  |  |  |

## Working

1. Compared Melanie Barcenas and Yazmeen Ryan and Emma Sears on 9 measures.
2. Melanie Barcenas leads on 2 of 9.
3. Yazmeen Ryan leads on 2 of 9.
4. Emma Sears leads on 0 of 9.
5. A measure with no value for one of them has no leader.
6. xG, xA, goals minus xG: the record holds these under another source's ids, which our identity register does not yet link to them.
7. Computed from 15 facts in 4 reads.

## Check it

- Verify: https://notebookfc.com/v/why-melanie-barcenas?w=2882841&x=27c12bf7&r=6bd8c7792d asks the question again and says whether this answer still stands.
- Recompute exactly: https://notebookfc.com/?a=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 regrows it at snapshot 2882841.
- Falsification: Wrong if the record at snapshot 2882841 holds different figures for either side of this comparison.

## Related questions

- https://notebookfc.com/ask/emma-sears
- https://notebookfc.com/ask/melanie-barcenas-assists
- https://notebookfc.com/ask/yazmeen-ryan-assists
- https://notebookfc.com/ask/emma-sears-assists
- https://notebookfc.com/ask/most-assists
